Famous and Forgotten: Soviet Sociology and the Nature of Intellectual Achievement under Totalitarianism

Mikhail Sokolov

Abstract


For decades Soviet and later post-Soviet sociology was dominated by a cohort of scholars born between 1927–1930 (Grushin, Kon, Levada, Ossipov, Yadov, Zaslavskaya). The origins of their prominence and the character of their recognition offers a puzzle as it seemingly defies conventional ideas about where academic renown comes from. Academic prominence is usually associated with either intellectual leadership or skillful manipulation of the academic power structures. Neither of these stories describes the peculiar pattern of recognition of the giants of Soviet sociology whose fame persisted after they retired from administrative responsibilities and in spite of their ideas from the Soviet era being almost forgotten. The hypothesis developed in this paper holds that this peculiar form of fame emerges from the unique position sociology held in Soviet society. The paper introduces a distinction between natural and intentional secrecy and argues that while most of Western sociology specialized in natural secrecy, Soviet sociology had to deal with intentional secrecy resulting from conscious attempts to conceal the dismal realities of state socialism. The pervasiveness of secrecy during the Soviet era resulted from the central legitimizing myth of Soviet society describing it as built following a scientifically devised plan. This legitimation allowed Soviet sociology to emerge and develop with an unparalleled speed, but, at the same time, it explains why sociology was seen as having considerable subversive potential and faced periodic repressions. This political environment accounts for Soviet sociology’s unique intellectual style as well as for the fact that its central figures remained in the disciplinary memory as heroic role models, rather than as authors of exemplary texts.


Full Text:

PDF

References


Abbott, Andrew (1986) Jurisdictional Conflicts: A New Approach to the Development of the Legal Professions, American Bar Foundation Research Journal 11 (2): 187-224.

Alekseev, A.N. (2005) Dramaticheskaja sociologija i sociologicheskaja autorefleksija [Dramatic sociology and sociological auto-reflection], Vol 2, Saint Petersburg: Norma.

Anikina, M.E, and V. M. Hrul (2010) Otkryvaja Grushina [Opening Grushin], Moskva: Izdatel'stvo MGU.

Batygin, G.S. (1991) Sovetskaja sociologija na zakate stalinskoj jery (Neskol'ko jepizodov) [Soviet sociology at the end of Stalin’s era (Some episodes)], Vestnik AN SSSR 10: 90-107.

Batygin, G.S. (1998) Preemstvennost' rossijskoj sociologicheskoj tradicii [The continuity of the Russian sociological tradition], in: V.A. Yadov (ed.) Sociologija v Rossii [Sociology in Russia], Moscow: Institute of sociology of the RAN Press, 1-42.

Batygin, G.S. (1999) Rossijskaja sociologija shestidesjatyh godov v vospominanijah i dokumentah [Russian sociology of the 1960s in recollections and documents], Saint Petersburg:: Russkij Hristianskij gumanitarnyj institute.

Beliaev, Edward, and Pavel Butorin (1982) The Institutionalization of Soviet Sociology: Its Social and Political Context, Social Forces 61 (2): 418-435.

Bikbov, A., and S. Gavrilenko (2002) Rossijskaja sociologija: avtonomija pod voprosom [Russian sociology: Autonomy under question], Logos 5-6: 1-40.

Bourdieu, Pierre (1988) Homo Academicus, Cambridge, UK : Polity Press.

Bozhkov, O.B., and T.Z. Protasenko (2005) Gljazhu v sebja kak v zerkalo jepohi [Looking at myself as a mirror of an epoch], Teleskop: Zhurnal sociologicheskih i marketingovyh issledovanij [The Telescope: Journal of sociological and market research] 6: 2-13.

Clark, Burton (1977) Academic power in Italy: Bureaucracy and oligarchy in a national university system. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

Clemens, Elizabeth, Walter Powell, Kris Mcllwaine, and Dina Okamoto (1995) Careers in Print: Books, Journals, and Scholarly Reputations, The American Journal of Sociology 101 (2): 433-494.

Coleman, James (1983) The Rational Reconstruction of Society, American Sociological Review 58 (1): 1-15.

Collins, Harry M. and Trevor Pinch (1998) The Golem: What You Should Know about Science. Cambridge; New York: Cambridge University Press.

Diamond Jr., A. M. (1980) Age and the acceptance of cliometrics, The Journal of Economic History 40 (4): 838-841.

DiMaggio, Paul and Walter Powell (1983) The Iron Cage Revisited: Institutional Isomorphism and Collective Rationality in Institutional Fields, The American Sociological Review 48 (2): 147-160.

Dimke, D.V. (2012) Klassiki bez klassiki: social'nye i kul'turnye istoki stilja sovetskoj sociologii [Classical authors without classical books: Social and cultural sources of Soviet sociology], Sociologicheskie issledovanija [Sociological research] 6: 97-107.

Doktorov, B. Z. (2005) Pervoprohodcy mira mnenij: ot Gjellapa do Grushina [Pioneers of the World of Opinions: From Gallup to Grushin], Moscow: Institut Fonda “Obshhestvennoe mnenie”.

Doktorov, B.Z. (2013) Sovremennaja rossijskaja sociologija: istorija v biografijah i biografii v istorii [Contemporary Russian sociology: History in biographies, biographies in history], SPb.: Izdatel'stvo EUSPb.

Filippov, A.F. (2013) Sovetskaja sociologija kak policejskaja nauka [Societ sociology as a police science], Novoe literaturnoe obozrenij [New Literary Review] 123 (3): 48-63.

Firsov, B.M. (2012) Istorija sovetskoj sociologii 1950–1980-h godov [The history of Soviet sociology, 1950-1980s], Saint Petersburg: Izdatel’stvo EUSPb.

Gibson, D. R. (2014). Enduring illusions: The social organization of secrecy and deception. Sociological Theory, 32(4), 283-306.

Glezerman, G.E., V. Zh. Kelle, and N.V. Pilipenko (1971) Istoricheskij materializm teorija i metod nauchnogo poznanija i revoljucionnogo dejstvija [Historical materialism as a theory and method of scientific understanding and revolutionary action], Kommunist 4: 60-70.

Goffman, Erving (1969) Expression Games. In Erving Goffman, Strategic Interaction. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press: 1-77.

Golosenko, I.A. and V.V. Kozlovskij (1995) Istorija russkoj sociologii XIX —XX vv. [The history of Russin sociology, XIX-XX centuries], Moscow: Onega.

Gorshkov, M.N. ( 2009)“Vivat, Yadov!”, Moscow: Novyj hronograf.

Gouldner, Alvin (1970) The Coming Crisis of Western Sociology, London: Heineman.

Greenfeld, Liah (1988) Soviet Sociology and Sociology in Soviet Union, Annual Review of Sociology 14: 99-123.

Grushin, B. A., Ja. S. Kapeljush, and L.N. Fedotova (1980) Massovaja informacija v sovetskom promyshlennom gorode [Mass information in a Soviet industrial city], Moskva: Politizdat.

Grushin, Boris (1999) Gor’kij vkus nevostrebovannosti [A bitter taste of being undemanded], in: G.S. Batygin (ed.) Rossijskaja sociologija shestidesjatyh godov v vospominanijah i dokumentah [Russian sociology of the 1960s in recollections and documents], Saint Petersburg: Russkij Hristianskij gumanitarnyj institute.

Grushin B.A. (2001) Chetyre zhizni Rossii v zerkale oprosov obshhestvennogo mnenija: ocherki massovogo soznanija rossijan vremen Hrushheva, Brezhneva, Gorbacheva i El'cina. Zhizn' 1-ja: Jepoha Hrushheva [Four lives of Russia in the mirror of public opinion polls: Essays of mass consciousness of the Russians in four epochs. Vol.1 Khruschev’s epoch], M.: Press-Tradicija.

Harrison, M. (2013). Accounting for secrets. The Journal of Economic History, 73(4), 1017-1049.

Hough, Jerry, and Merle Fainsod (1979) How the Soviet Union is Governed, Cambridg: Harvard University Press.

Jones, B., E.J. Reedy, and B. Weinberg (2014) Age and Scientific Genius, in: Dean Simonton (ed.) Handbook of Genius, Malden; Oxford: Wiley Blackwell, 422-450.

Kon, I.S. (1999) Jepohu ne vybirajut [Epoch is not to be chosen], in: G.S. Batygin (ed.) Rossijskaja sociologija shestidesjatyh godov v vospominanijah i dokumentah [Russian sociology of the 1960s in recollections and documents], Saint Petersburg: Russkij Hristianskij gumanitarnyj institute, 110-131.

Kon, I.S. (2008) 80 let odinochestva [80 years of loneliness], Moskva: Vremja.

Maksimov, B.I. (2010) “Zvezdnye chasy” piterskoj sociologii [The peak moments of Petersburg sociology], Teleskop: Zhurnal sociologicheskih i marketingovyh issledovanij [Telescope: A Journal of Sociologucal and market Research] 6: 17-19.

Meyer, John, and Evan Schofer (2005) The Worldwide Expansion of Higher Education in the Twentieth Century, American Sociological Review 70 (6): 898-920.

Moskvichev, L.N. (1997) Sociologija i vlast'. Sbornik. Dokumenty: 1953–1968 [Sociology and Power. Documents: 1953-1968], Moscow: Academia.

Lamont, Michele (2009) How Professors Think. Inside the Curious World of Academic Judgment, Cambridge: Harvard University Press.

Latour, Bruno, and Steve Woolgar (1979) Laboratory Life: The Social Construction of Scientific Facts, London; Beverley Hills: Sage.

Levada, T.V. (2011) Pamjati Jurija Aleksandrovicha Levady [Remembering Yuri Levada], Moskva: Izdatel' Karpov E.V.

Levada, Ju.A. (2011) Sochinenija. Lekcii po sociologii [Lectures on sociology], Moskva: Izdatel' Karpov E.V.

Najmann, Jake, and Belinda Hewitt (2004) The Validity of Publication and Citation Counts for Sociology and Other Selected Disciplines, Journal of Sociology 39 (1): 62-80.

Ossipov, G.V., and L.N. Moskvichev (2008) Sociologija i vlast' (kak jeto bylo na samom dele) [Sociology and power (how it really was)], Moskva: Jekonomika.

Ossipov, G.V. (2013) Takoj istorii sociologii net ni u odnoj iz zarubezhnyh stran. Jeto tragicheskaja, dramaticheskaja istorija [None of foreign sociologies has such a history. This is a tragic, dramatic history], Teleskop: Zhurnal sociologicheskih i marketingovyh issledovanij [The Telescope: A Journal of Sociological and Market Research] 4: 2-9.

Ossipov, G.V. (1970) Sovetskaja sociologicheskaja associacija. Informacionnyj bjulleten N. 37 [Soviet sociological association. A directory], Moskva: IKSI AN.

Radaev, V.V., and B.Ju. Starcev (2008) Jekonomicheskaja sociologija v Rossii: pokolenie uchitelej [Economic sociology in Russia: A generation of teachers], Moskva: GU VShJe.

Rusalinova, A.A. (2008) Leningradskaja sociologicheskaja shkola 60-80-h gg. 20 veka i jempiriko-prikladnye issledovanija na promyshlennyh predprijatijah [Leningrad sociological school of 1960-80s and empirical and applied research at industrial enterprises], in: A.O. Boronoev (ed.) Rossijskaja sociologija. Vol. 4: Sociologija v Leningrade – Sankt-Peterburge vo vtoroj polovine 20 veka [Russian sociology. Vol.4. Sociology in Leningrad-Saint Petersburg in the second half of XX century], Saint Petersburg: Saint Petersburg university press, 59-87.

Scott, Richard, and John Meyer (1994) Institutional Environments and Organizations: Structural Complexity and Individualism, Thousand Oaks: Sage.

Shapin, Steven (1995) A Social History of Truth: Civility and Science in Seventeenth-Century England, Chicago; London: University of Chicago Press.

Simmel, Georg (1906) The Sociology of Secrecy and of the Secret Societies. American Journal of Sociology, 11(4): 441-498.

Shils, Edward (1970) Tradition, Ecology, and Institution in the History of Sociology, Daedalus 99 (4): 760-825.

Shlapentokh, Vladimir (1987) The Politics of the Sociology in the Soviet Union, Boulder; London: Westview Press.

Sokolov, Mikhail (2011) Rynki truda, stratifikacija i kar'ery v sovetskoj sociologii [Labor markets, stratification, and careers in Soviet sociology], Jekonomicheskaja sociologija [Economic sociology] 12 (4): 37-72.

Sokolov, Mikhail, and Anastasya Kincharova (2015) Issledovatel’skie praktiki rossijskih sotsiologov [Russian sociologists: A history of research practices]. Sotsiologicheskie issledovanija [Sociological research] 6: 58-68.

Starr, Paul (1982) The Social Transformation of American Medicine, New York: Basic Books.

Toshhenko, Zh.T. (2007) Sociologija v nashej strane vozrodilas' snachala kak politicheskaja vitrine. Interv'ju B.Z. Doktorovu, Sociologicheskij zhurnal 4: 149-170.

Tse-Tang, Wan, Yeo-Chi King, Ambrose. (1978) The Development and Death of Chinese Academic Sociology: A Chapter in Sociology of Sociology. Modern Asian Studies, 12(1): 37-58.

Turner, Stephen, and Jonathan Turner (1990) The Impossible Science: An Institutional Analysis of American Sociology, Newbury Park: Sage.

Weinberg, Elizabeth A. (2004) Sociology in the Soviet Union and Beyond. Social Enquiry and Social Change, Farnham: Ashgate.

Wiley, Norbert (1979) The rise and fall of dominating theories in American sociology, in: W. E. Snizek, E. F. Fuhrmann, and M.K. Miller (eds.) Contemporary Issues in Theory and Research: A metasociological perspective, Westport: Greenwood Press, 49-78.

Wray, Brad (2003) Is Science Really a Young Man’s Game?, Social Studies of Science 33 (1): 137-149.

Yadov, V.A. (1979) Samoreguljacija i prognozirovanie social'nogo povedenija lichnosti [Self-regulation and forecasting of an individual’s social behavior], Leningrad: Nauka.

Yadov, V.A. (2015) Memuar o tom, kak razrabatyvalas' dispozicionnaja koncepcija [A note on how a dispositional conception was developed], Teleskop: Zhurnal sociologicheskih i marketingovyh issledovanij [The Telescope: A Journal of Sociological and Market Research] 4: 48.

Zaslavskaja, T.I. (2007) Izbrannoe [Selected writings]. Moskva: Jekonomika.

Zdravomyslova, Elena, and Larissa Titarenko (2017) Sociology in Russia. A Brief History, Basingstokre: Palgrave Macmillan.

Zemtsov, Ilya (1985) Soviet Sociology: A Study of Lost Illusions in Russia under Soviet Control of Society. Fairfax: Hero Books


Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.


  • Editors
  • Peter Baehr (Lingnan University, Hong Kong),
  • Fernanda Beigel (Universidad Nacional de Cuyo, Mendoza, Argentina),
  • Christian Fleck (University of Graz, Austria),
  • Andreas Hess (University College Dublin, Ireland),
  • Laurent Jeanpierre (Université Paris 8, Vincennes-Saint-Denis, France)
  • Olessia Kirtchik (National Research University, Higher School of Economics, Moscow, Russia)
  • Thomas Koenig (Institute for Advanced Studies, Vienna, Austria)
  • George Steinmetz (University of Michigan, USA)
  •  
  • Managing Editors
  • Matthias Duller (University of Graz, Austria)
  • Carl Neumayr (University of Graz, Austria) 
  • Associate Editors
  • Ivan Boldyrev (Radboud University, Nijmegen, Netherlands)
  • Thibaud Boncourt (Université Paris 1 Panthéon Sorbonne, France)
  • Matteo Bortolini (University of Padua, Italy)
  • Marcia Consolim (Universidade Federal de São Paulo, Brazil)
  • Christian Dayé (Alpen-Adria University Klagenfurt, Austria)
  • Jefferson Pooley (Muhlenberg College, Allentown PA, USA)
  • Elisabeth Simbürger (Universidad de Valparaíso, Chile)
  •  
  • Book review Editor
  • Kristoffer Kropp (Roskilde University, Denmark) 

  • Language Editor
  • Kate Forbes-Pitt 
  • International Advisory Board
  • Richard Bellamy (University College London, United Kingdom)
  • Mark Bevir (University of California, Berkeley, USA)
  • Peter Breiner (State University of New York, USA)
  • Peter Burke (University of Cambridge, Emmanuel College, United Kingdom)
  • Hamilton Cravens (Iowa State University, USA) †
  • Paul H. Erickson (Wesleyan University, USA)
  • Jean-Louis Fabiani (Central European University, Budapest and Ecole des Hautes Etudes en Sciences Sociales, Paris)
  • Liah Greenfeld (Boston University, USA)
  • Johan Heilbron (Erasmus University, Rotterdam and Centre de sociologie européenne, Paris)
  • Dirk Kaesler (University of Marburg, Germany)
  • Michèle Lamont (Harvard University, USA)
  • Wolf Lepenies (Wissenschaftskolleg zu Berlin, Germany)
  • Sergio Miceli (Universidade de São Paulo, Brasil)
  • Philip E. Mirowski, (University of Notre Dame, USA)
  • Helga Nowotny (ETH Zurich, Switzerland)
  • William Outhwaite (Newcastle University, United Kingdom)
  • Margaret Schabas (University of British Columbia, Canada)
  • Cherry Schrecker (Université Grenoble-Alpes, France)
  • Peter D. Simonson (University of Colorado, USA)
  • Pierre Singaravélou (Université Paris 1 Panthéon-Sorbonne, France)
  • Friedrich Stadler (University of Vienna, Austria)
  • Nico Stehr (Zeppelin University, Friedrichshafen, Germany)
  • Eleanor R. Townsley (Mount Holyoke College, USA)
  • Stephen P. Turner (University of South Florida, USA)
  • Gary Wickham (Murdoch University, Australia),